Quantcast
Channel: Critical Beauty

My Top 10 Favorites For Miss Earth 2023

$
0
0

 

In this vlog, I reveal my top 10 favorites for Miss Earth 2023 whose finals will take place in Vietnam on December 22, 2023.





Albania Wins Miss Earth 2023

$
0
0

 



Drita Ziri, 18, of Albania has been crowned Miss Earth 2023 in Van Phuc City, Vietnam on December 22. She is the first Albanian to win the Miss Earth title and the first to win a major international pageant. Ziri previously competed at The Miss Globe 2022 competition representing Albania and placed 2nd Runner-up.

Her court includes:
Miss Earth Air 2023 - Yllana Aduana, Philippines
Miss Earth Water 2023 - Do Thi Lan Anh, Vietnam
Miss Earth Fire 2023 - Cora Bliault, Thailand

Rounding up the top 8 (all named “Miss Earth 2023 Runner-Up”) were:
Morgana Carlos - Brazil
Dilnaz Tilaeva - Kazakhstan
Noa Claus - Netherlands
Daria Lukonkina - Russia

Congratulations to the winners!



My Recap & Review of Miss Earth 2023 Finals

$
0
0

 In this vlog, I do a recap and review of Miss Earth 2023 finals that took place in Vietnam on December 22, 2023.




End Of The Year Review 2023

$
0
0

And the winner is... Miss Drama. Runners-up are Miss Money and Miss Narcissist.


      2023 pageantry can be described easily in one word: self-conscious. Virtually anyone involved in pageantry has experienced some level of uneasiness caused by uncertainty or skepticism. All of a sudden, being conscious of one's appearance and behavior has been replaced by being conscious of what others may think of you. This phenomenon best describes the two most powerful and influential pageant bosses - Nawat Itsaragrisil, the president of Miss Grand International, and Anne Jakrajutatip, the owner of Miss Universe. Once very good friends, the couple has been competing with each other for grand and universal attention ever since the two split. They would do anything to extend their sphere of influence and pump up their power either by selling merchandise, exploiting the Israel-Palestine conflict or delaying debt payment. Both have strong personalities, both think outside the box, but also both possess fragile Thai egos. Other than that, some individuals rose to the occasion, beating the odds and manifesting their gospel truth - which was the only way to shatter the adverse perception of themselves by the critical public.

____________________



AGE-LESS:  R’Bonney Gabriel, Miss USA, was crowned Miss Universe 2022 on January 14 in New Orleans. Her victory marks USA’s 9th Miss Universe crown and makes her the oldest winner at 28 years of age. During the finals, Gabriel was asked: "Miss Universe made an inclusive change allowing mothers and married women to compete this year. What's another change you would like to see and why?""For me I would like to see an age increase because I am 28 years old and that is the oldest age you compete. And I think it's a beautiful thing. My favorite quote is 'if not now then when?' Because as a woman, I believe age doesn't define us. It's not tomorrow, it's not yesterday, but it's now. The time is now that you can go after what you want." Eight months later, the Miss Universe Organization, inspired by Gabriel’s response, decided to remove the age restrictions. 

____________________ 


VICTORY FOR MISS FRANCE: On January 8, Paris court said that the Miss France contest was not discriminatory in the way it selected candidates. The judgment came in response to a case filed by a feminist group "Osez le féminisme" (Dare to be a Feminist), along with three failed contestants. The case was filed in October 2021 alleging that the contest was breaking French labor laws as the companies were discriminatory by asking contestants aspiring to be beauty queens to be more than 1.70 meters tall, single, and "representative of beauty". This is a big sigh of relief for private groups and companies who want to establish their own rules and regulations that would fit their brand and vision.  

____________________


HERE SHE IS, MISS AMERICA CEO: On January 26, it was announced that Robin Ross Fleming became the new CEO (Chief Empowerment Officer) of the Miss America Organization. Fleming used to direct the Miss Florida USA system for several years. Fleming made some changes within the system, such as replacing the word “candidate” with “delegate” or “contestant”. She also raised the Miss age limit from 25 to 28. Regarding the teen division, the age requirement will remain 13-18 years of age with the teen pageant now recognized as Miss America’s Teen” after removing the “Outstanding” reference previously branded.

____________________



WORLDLY EMBARRASSMENT: On February 13, 2023,  the Miss World Organization (MWO) whose CEO is Julia Morley, announced that the United Arab Emirates. Four months later, on 8 June 2023, MWO announced that the competition was moved to India instead of the United Arab Emirates. On September 28, 2023, MWO announced that the pageant will take place  on December 16, 2023 in Delhi, India. However, due to the elections in India, the pageant has been postponed until March 2, 2024. Finally, on December 19, MWO changed the date again. Instead of March 2, 2024, the contest has now been delayed for another week, for March 9, 2024.    The host city for the final has not been specified yet. 

____________________


BIGGER AND BETTER: Madison Anderson, who represented Puerto Rico in Miss Universe 2019 and placed first runner-up, won the third season of the  popular Spanish-language reality show, “La Casa de los Famosos” which was broadcasted by Telemundo on April 24.

____________________


BAD, BAD LADY: On April 28,  Mary Wickersham, 77, the former executive director of the Miss Florida pageant, has been sentenced to more than a year in federal prison for stealing hundreds of thousands of dollars from the organization. Wickersham began serving as the executive director of the Miss Florida Scholarship Program in 2002.

____________________



TRANS-FORMATIONAL HISTORY: On July 8, Rikki Kollé became the first transgender woman  to be crowned Miss Universe Netherlands. On October 5, Marina Machete became the first transgender woman to be crowned Miss Universe Portugal. Both women competed in Miss Universe 2023 in El Salvador on November 18 where Machete ended up as a semifinalist. Trans activist Federico Barbarossa entered the Miss Italy 2023 pageant after its organizer said trans women were not allowed. His protest went viral and more than 100 trans men signed up.

____________________



MOTHERS RULE: Ever since Miss Universe updated its entry requirements by allowing married/divorced mothers and pregnant women, countries have been aggressively recruiting women who carry any of these traits to enter national pageants. On August 10, Michele Cohn, 28, became the first married mother to win Miss Universe Guatemala.  On September 2, Camila Avella, 28, became the first married mother to win Miss Universe Colombia. On July 8, one of the top 7 finalists was Renata Guerra, a married mother. On December 7, Ileana Marquez,  a 28-year-old mother of an 11 year-old girl, was crowned Miss Venezuela 2023. Though not a mother yet, Juliana Morehouse, Miss Maine USA 2023, got married on April 29 which instantly made her the first contestant to be officially recognized as a married woman to compete in Miss USA.

____________________



SIGNIFICANT VICTORIES:  On February 2 in Dubai, Valentina Sanchez of Venezuela was crowned as the first Universal Woman winner; she was Miss Supranational Venezuela 2021 and Miss New Jersey Teen USA 2014 . On February 16, Luma Russo of Brazil became the first woman and the first Brazilian woman to be crowned Miss Charm. Athenea Perez became the first black woman to win Miss Universe Spain held on July 1. Natasha Joubert, who had competed in Miss South Africa 2020 placing second, returned to compete again in 2023 and won the coveted crown on August 13. The 25-year-old model and entrepreneur was trying her luck for the second time as new rules to enter the pageant were  introduced earlier this year.  On September 14, Erica Robin became the first Miss Universe Pakistan; due to Pakistan’s anti-pageant politics, Robin was crowned in the Maldives. She then competed in Miss Universe 2023, wore a kaftan during the swimsuit segment and managed to place in the top 20, giving Pakistan its first ever placement.



On September 29, Noelia Voigt of Utah became the first woman of Venezuelan descent to be crowned Miss USA. Luciana Fuster, an artist and brand ambassador with 5 million followers, was crowned Miss Grand International 2023 on October 25 in Vietnam, making Peru the first country to get its second crown in the pageant’s 11-year history. On November 18 in El Salvador, Sheynnis Palacios became the first Nicaraguan woman to be crowned Miss Universe and the only second Central American winner after Justine Pasek in 2002. On December 22 in Vietnam,  Drita Ziri made history by becoming the first Albanian to win Miss Earth and the first Albanian to win a major international pageant. 

____________________



CONTROVERSIAL QUEENS: Following her appointment as Miss Grand U.S. Virgin Islands 2023, Heather Marie Thompson was heavily bullied online by the islanders who claimed that she is not a true representative of the islands because she was not born and raised or even lives there. Mileidy Materano was also viciously attacked on social media by the citizens of Trinidad & Tobago when she was crowned as the country’s representative to Miss Grand International 2023. Materano was born and raised in Venezuela and has only lived in the islands for six years. She agreed to resign from her post, but her lawyer claims that her decision to resign was not a result of public pressure but due to financial constraints. Miss Universe Nepal Jane Dipika Garrett made history by becoming the first plus-size contestant to place in Miss Universe. However, her critics argue that forced inclusion was the only reason she earned a spot. Also, videoclips of Garrett behaving badly during the competition surfaced on social media, which prompted fans and some contestants to question if bad behavior is rewarded in the pageant. On December 16, Eve Gilles was crowned Miss France 2024; critics slammed the 20-year-old because of her short hair and androgynous look, stating that she does not represent the classic French beauty with long hair and curvy figure. Gilles clapped back at her haters by saying that “No one should dictate who you are” and that every woman is unique.

____________________



WILL THE REAL OWNER PLEASE STAND UP: On August 22, three influential pageant portals (Critical Beauty, Global Beauties, Missosology) released a joint statement recognizing Thailand’s Pradit Pradinunt, the CEO of Mister Global, as the sole and legal proprietor of Mister International, and not Manuel Deldio, the self-proclaimed lawyer who claims that Alan Sim, the founder of Mister International, had assigned him to be Sim’s successor even though Deldio could not provide legitimate evidence for his claim. On September 25, the Thai court ruled in favor of Pradinunt. Deldio organized an illegitimate version of Mister International in October; not only did he fail to produce a top-notch show (with less than 30 contestants many of whom were male models already living and working in the Philippines), he also managed to scam the Argentine delegate, Angel Olaya, by not reimbursing the money that Olaya had spent to travel to the Philippines (the note posted above by Olaya shows that Deldio had promised to pay him back.)

____________________



JUSTIFIED CONDEMNATION: On her Instagram post published in October 16, Miss Israel 2013 Yityish “Titi” Aynaw, who is of Ethiopian descent, slammed activist groups such as Black Lives Matter for not supporting the Jewish people terrorized by Hamas during its surprise attacks on innocent Israeli civilians on October 7. “I am so shocked by the response of Black Lives Matter regarding the terror attacks here in Israel. I remember you screaming in the streets, ‘I can’t breathe.’ I want to inform you right now … [it’s Israelis] who cannot breathe.” She invoked some 200 Israeli hostages held in Gaza — including babies, children, women, entire families and the elderly. Two months later, Another Israeli ex-beauty queen Linor Abargil, who was crowned Miss World 1998, slammed the United Nations Organization and women’s groups for not condemning Hamas violence against Israeli women during an appearance on Fox News on December 7.  ‘It’s not about which side you are on the map,’ said Linor Abargil, herself a rape survivor. ‘To use rape as an act of war is unbearable’. Abargil was raped and stabbed in Italy just weeks before she was crowned Miss World.  

____________________

MOST BITTER PERSON OF THE YEAR: On her Facebook post dated January 16, 2023 which had already been deleted, Miss Universe Puerto Rico Ashley Cariño’s mother, Arline Cariño, blames her daughter’s loss to MUO’s favoritism towards Miss USA R’Bonney Gabriel, saying that Gabriel’s victory was part of the deal under the new ownership. Arline also said that neither the Dominican Republic nor Venezuela deserved to be in the top 3 and that Puerto Rico was excluded because she was the biggest threat. Arline also stated, among several things, that the pageant should not be the platform to seek equality for different genders, which was the first message that “Aunt Anne” (referring to the new owner who is a transgender woman) sent and that she has nothing against other communities who already have their own contests. She ended her lengthy post by spewing the F-word and insulting missosologists (pageant experts): “I don’t know where the hell they got that ill-founded title that doesn’t exist since to obtain a title you have to study and become a professional and nothing to do with all these hypocrites and more, ours only want guidelines and benefits and if I continue, I will not stop.”

____________________

NOT CRYSTLE CLEAR: On September 29, a documentary entitled “How To Fix A Pageant,” was shown on FX channel. The documentary features several Miss USA 2022 contestants who alleged that the Miss USA organization was guilty of  everything from sexual harassment by its Vice President Max Sebrechts, the husband of Miss USA President Crystle Stewart, to rigging - claiming that there was big favoritism towards eventual winner, R’Bonney Gabriel from Texas. The complainants, headed by Miss Montana USA 2022 Heather Lee O’Keefe, said that Stewart had “something to hide” after the 2022 rigging scandal erupted. Stewart appeared stiff throughout her interview and often glanced toward her lawyer, Nathan Sheffield, who once had to step in to coach her on how to respond. The broadcast of the documentary took place on the same day that Miss USA 2023 coronation night was being held in Reno, Nevada. Stewart denied that the pageant had been rigged and claimed that the results had been verified by an accountant other than Ernst & Young, the accountants that Miss USA had been using before Stewart took over the organization. 

____________________

UNIVERSAL WOES: Last March, Pranome Thavaravej, who was hired by the Miss Universe Organization to be the official chauffeur to Miss Universe R’Bonney Gabriel and finalists Andreina Martinez, and Gabriëla Dos Santos during their trip to Thailand in February, said that she has not been paid for her work. “Miss Universe doesn't pay their employees. I have been waiting for 3 months for my payment.” 

On November 9,  JKN Global, whose CEO is Anne Jakrajutatip, the owner of Miss Universe, filed for “debt rehabilitation” to seek to adjust interest rates and to extend its debt repayment period. “JKN will receive financial support from new investors or financial institutions to provide working capital. Non-productive assets would be sold to generate income to repay debts,” according to Jakrajutatip. JKN, which bought the Miss Universe Organization for $20 million in October last year, has delayed some payments for its bonds, citing global and domestic economic challenges.  

____________________

GRAND GLORIES: In late January, Miss Grand International filed an IPO (Initial Public Offering) which allows MGI to list its shares on a stock exchange, making them available for purchase by the general public. On December 13,  MGI  officially became a  public company and celebrated the opening of its stock trading for the first time on the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The entire MGI 2023 team was present with Miss Grand Thailand 2022 Engfa Waraha ringing the bell. The first trading day immediately proved to be a big success. MGI closed the market with 8.5 bahts to 4.9 bahts (71.72%).

____________________

FRANCHISES LOST: On February 8, Miss Universe Organization took away the Indonesian franchise from Yayasan Puteri Indonesia (YPI) and gave it to Poppy Capella, allegedly a good friend of MUO owner Anne Jakrajutatip. According to YPI spokesperson Mega Angkasa, YPI offered more money to MUO to keep the franchise, but it was rejected and MUO gave the franchise to Capella instead. Angkasa also said, "We felt there was an injustice because YPI was only given 3 working days while national directors from other countries got a grace period of 5-10 days. We were not given a proper bidding format, while other countries get detailed bidding formats." Capella was also awarded the Malaysian franchise. However, six months after acquiring the franchise for two countries, MUO cut ties with Capella after allegations of six Miss Universe Indonesia contestants alleged that they were ordered to strip to their underwear for “body checks.” Five of the contestants said they were then photographed topless. MUO released a statement condemning the allegations. “In light of what we have learned took place at Miss Universe Indonesia, it has become clear that this franchise has not lived up to our brand standards and ethics,” the Miss Universe Organization said on X (formerly known as Twitter).

On February 10, the Miss Universe Ghana Organization released a statement announcing that they would not renew the franchise because MUO's new business model no longer conforms with theirs.  Vietnam, Belize, Mauritius, Seychelles followed suit. On March 2, the Miss Universe Cambodia Organization released a statement announcing that their franchise application has not been approved by MUO, making them the fourth group from Southeast Asia to lose the franchise (after Indonesia, Malaysia and Vietnam). 

Lupita Jones, who had been directing Miss Universe Mexico for over 20 years, has lost the Mexican franchise to big-time entrepreneur Raul Rocha Cantu. Meanwhile,  Cynthia de la Vega, a former Miss World Mexico 2010 (who represented the state of Nuevo León) whom Lupita had dethroned for having gained weight before competing in Miss World 2011 contest, will be the new national director. In August, MUO decided to cut ties with Miss USA President Crystle Stewart. On December 29, Henrique Fontes, the director of Concurso Nacional de Beleza (Miss Brasil), announced on his Instagram page that the Brazilian franchise for Miss Grand International had been taken away from him and given to someone else who had placed a higher bid. Under Fontes’s directorship, Brazil made the top 5 of MGI for four consecutive years, culminating in the 2022 victory of Isabella Menin whom many fans think is the most beautiful winner so far.

____________________

FRANCHISES GAINED: Just a few days after Lupita Jones lost the Mexican franchise for Miss Universe, she was offered the Mexican franchise for Miss Grand International which she accepted. Multimedia personality and pageant coach Evandro Hazzy hinted on his Instagram stories that he is the new Brazilian franchisee for Miss Grand International and intends to bring the pageant to Brazil in the future. Señorita Panama Organization regained the Miss Universe license after the outgoing licensee Miss Universe Panama Organization - claiming that MUO is a fraudulent organization -  decided not to renew it for 2024. Concurso Nacional de Belleza Ecuador, led by siblings Tahiz and Miguel Panus, gained the Ecuadorian franchise for Miss Universe after placing a higher bid than outgoing franchisee Miss Ecuador Organization. Magali Febles, the long-time director of Miss Universe Dominican Republic, acquired the Dominican franchise for Mister and Miss Supranational.

____________________

BEHAVING BADLY: Véronique Michielsen, who was originally crowned as Miss Grand Ecuador 2023 last May and was supposed to compete in Miss Grand International 2023 finals in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam on October 25, was stripped of her title because she got pregnant. In July, Jennifer Barrantes was dethroned from her title as Miss World Peru 2022, according to a statement released by the Miss World Peru Organization. Barrantes, who was crowned last September 2022, has not been preparing herself for Miss World 2023 and has been unable to fulfill her obligations that include promoting social causes. Elena Correa, who was Miss Costa Rica 2017 and represented her country in Miss Universe 2017, was arrested in June for computer theft and allegedly stealing more than $40,000 dollars, valuables, luxury watches and even the passport of her elderly husband, Carlos Rodríguez.  

____________________

RESIGNATIONS & RETIREMENTS: The acquisition of Miss Universe by JKN Global resulted in several administrative changes that included a bidding war among potential franchise applicants, which resulted in the departure of several directors who did not agree with the new agreement. Structural changes within MUO also materialized, beginning with the departure of franchise director Carlos Capetillo in February, followed in March by talent manager Esther Swan (who had been with the company for 22 years), and in November by Paula Shugart who announced during the Miss Universe 2023 preliminary show that she would be resigning as president after 23 years. On December 8, the Miss Panama Organization (MPO) released a statement announcing that it will not renew its license with MUO after only two years. The organization believes that the recent changes in the organization under JKN Global no longer conform to MPO’s values.



On December 12, Karen Celebertti announced that she was stepping down as Nicaragua’s national director, less than a month after Miss Nicaragua Sheynnis Palacios was crowned Miss Universe 2023. Her decision comes on the heels of the oppressive government of Nicaragua, led by longtime dictator Daniel Ortega, who has banned Karen from returning to the country after she and her husband were accused of being traitors against the government. Meanwhile, the acquisition of Miss USA by Laylah Rose in August led to the departure of the state directors for seven states in the first week of December. All of them share the same sentiment expressed by Melissa Proctor-Pitchford that “recent changes within the organization, controversial incidents that have taken place, and an unpredictable future, no longer align with both my personal and professional standards, integrity, and ethics.” 

____________________

GRAND STORIES: The preliminary swimsuit competition of Miss Grand International 2023 attracted huge viewership - and harsh criticism - because it was held outdoors during a rainy day in Da Nang. Some of the girls slipped and fell on their buttocks as they reached a wet and slippery station. Luckily, no one was seriously hurt. The organizers decided to annul the competition and to replace it with another one held indoors on dry floor. Kathryn Fanshawe, Miss Grand Wales 2020 turned national director for Miss Grand United Kingdom, published in her story that several 2023 contestants  had been arriving late (sometimes an hour). She warned them that their every  move was being watched and noted by MGI president Nawat Itsaragrisil and tardiness could cost them a placement. During the preliminary interviews, Miss Grand Greece 2023 Ioanna Skoula boldly stated that she would not win because none of the contestants supported her. Itsaragrisil selected only thirteen girls for a private interview, and all of them made the top 20 during the finals.  After competing in Miss Grand International 2023, Miss Grand Venezuela 2023 Valentina Martinez took to her Instagram page  to explain her sudden weight gain caused by a mysterious medical condition. When she didn’t make the top 20, Venezuelan fans started attacking her on social media. The Top 10 finalists of Miss Grand International 2023 took to their social media to defend the MGI organization from attacks by toxic fans. The posts came on the heels of the video featuring former Miss Universe PhilippinesMary Jane Lastimosa asking a Filipina trans woman celebrity Maki Gingoyon what the worst pageant in the Philippines is and Maki replied,  “Miss Grand.”

____________________

Eight years since the most controversial crowning moment in Miss Universe history that occurred on December 20, 2015, Miss Universe Philippines 2015 Pia Wurtzbach and Miss Universe Colombia 2015 Ariadna Gutierrez reunited, much to the delight of pageant fans all over the world.  “The reunion you’ve all been waiting for,” Wurtzbach wrote on September 26, alongside photos with Gutierrez as they walked the streets of Paris, France. The two were in the country for Paris Fashion Week.  Gutierrez also shared her happiness in seeing Wurtzbach again. “It’s been almost eight years since the last time we were together. So happy to see you again,” she wrote. In a separate Instagram story, she added: “When time makes sure you meet the right people once again.”

____________________
 

Winners of Significant International Pageants Held in 2023


Miss Aura International - Thailand - Ketwalee Phonbodi

Miss Charm - Brazil - Luma Russo

Miss CosmoWorld - USA - Shelby Howell

Miss Earth - Albania - Drita Ziri

Miss Friendship International - China - Zhu Zi-Ying

Miss Grand International - Peru - Luciana Fuster

Miss Intercontinental - Thailand - Chatnalin Chotjirawarachat

Miss International - Venezuela - Andrea Rubio

Miss International Queen - Netherlands - Solange Dekker

Miss Supranational  - Ecuador - Andrea Aguilera

Miss Tourism International - Thailand - Tia Li Taveepanichpan

Miss Universe 2022 (held on January 14, 2023)  - USA - R’Bonney Gabriel

Miss Universe 2023 - Nicaragua - Sheynnis Palacios

Reina Hispanoamericana 2022 (held on March 25, 2023) - Arlette Rujel

Reina Internacional del Café - Colombia - Isabella Bermúdez 

The Miss Globe - Malaysia - Manvin Khera

Caballero Universal - Dominican Republic - Leonardo Mendoza 

Man of the World - Korea - Jin Wook Kim

Mister Friendship International - Cambodia - Leav Veng Hour

Mister Global 2022 (held on February 13, 2023) - Cuba - Juan Carlos Ariosa

Mister Global 2023 - India - Jason Bretfelean 

Mister International  - Thailand - Kim Woodburn

Mister Supranational - Spain - Ivan Alvarez Guedes

____________________

IN MEMORIAM


On March 19, Marisol Malaret Contreras, the first Puerto Rican woman crowned Miss Universe in 1970, died from complications of a pulmonary condition. She was 73. Her homecoming to Puerto Rico after winning Miss Universe was considered one of the biggest ever at that time, with around 50,000 attending to see her in person. After her reign, she appeared on several commercials and did modeling work before becoming the editor-of-chief of Caras Magazine for several years.

Jerry Springer, the former Cincinnati mayor who rose to tremendous fame as a syndicated talk show host, died on April 27 from pancreatic cancer. He was 79. Pageant fans will remember Springer as the host of Miss World 2000 and 2001 as well as a co-host of Miss Universe 2008.

Bob Barker, American media personality and animal rights advocate who was a long-time host of the game shows “The Price Is Right” and “Truth or Consequences”, as well as  Miss Universe and Miss USA pageants, died on August 26 from Alzheimer’s Disease. Barker stepped down from hosting the Miss USA 1987 pageant when the producers refused his request to remove fur prizes.

 Geneviève de Fontenay, also known as The Lady In The Hat (because she was rarely seen without one) who was responsible for directing the Miss France Organization from 1981 to 2009, died on August 1st at the age of 90.  Defending a conservative image of femininity, she gradually became ostracized and withdrew from public life. She was charged in June with insults and incitement to transphobic discrimination. Under her directorship, Miss France became a popular annual television event seen by millions around world.

Sherika De Armas, Miss World Uruguay 2015, died on October 13 at the age of 26 after her battle with cervical cancer. 


Text by Rafa Delfin, 1/1/2024


Critical Beauty Group Chats - Some Highlights From 2023

$
0
0


Looking back at the group chats that I hosted in 2023, I didn’t realize that I had conducted ten of them! There were so many interesting topics covered, and so many amazing conversation among my guests and me. I created a short compilation of some of the highlights from 2023 to give new and future subscribers and viewers a taste of what to expect from this channel, besides a critical analysis of pageants.



 

The Best & Worst of Pageantry In 2023

$
0
0

 

This group chat was conducted via Zoom on Saturday, January 13, 2024 at 9:30 PM EST. My guests include Ed Dominguez (formerly of Global Beauties and license holder of Miss World Panama), Wilfredo Lopez (runway coach and mentor), Brian Javier (pageant blogger and national director of Miss Grand US Virgin Islands) and Lenka Vomocil (Mrs. National Universe 2022 and social media manager).




Madison Marsh Crowned Miss America 2024

$
0
0



Madison Marsh, Miss Colorado, has been crowned Miss America 2024 in Orlando, Florida on January 14.

The 22-year-old beauty makes history by being the first active duty Air Force pilot to compete in the pageant and now the first of her kind to win the title. Her platform is pancreatic cancer awareness.

I featured her three days ago. 🤗

Her court includes:

1st runner-up - Texas - Ellie Breaux
2nd runner-up - Indiana - Cydney Bridges
3rd runner-up - Kentucky - Mallory Hudson
4th runner-up - Rhode Island - Caroline Parente

Completing the top 11 are the contestants from North Carolina, Kansas, Maryland, Florida, New York and Arkansas.

This is the first edition of Miss America under the new directorship of Robin Fleming. The show was streamed live for free for the global audience. I thought the production was fast-paced, the opening number was entertaining, and the overall stage presentation was well executed. It is always heart-warming to see past titleholders gracing the stage (from 1964 to 2018). My only major critique is that the two co-hosts were too chatty and that the musical performance was scarce.


PHOTOS COURTESY OF MISS AMERICA ORGANIZATION


Puerto Rico Wins Miss Global 2023

$
0
0

 


Ashley Melendez of Puerto Rico has been crowned Miss Global 2023 in Cambodia during the pageant’s tenth edition on January 18. She is the first woman from the island country to win the crown.

Melendez had competed in Miss Earth Puerto Rico 2023 where she placed second and won the title of Miss Global Puerto Rico 2023.

1st Runner-Up - Haylani Kuruppu, Samoa
2nd Runner-Up - Chonnikarn Supittayaporn
3rd Runner-Up - Pearl Hung, Philippines
4th Runner-Up - Doan Thu Thuy, Vietnam

Congratulations to the top 5!




Miss USA 2022 Morgan Romano Spills The Tea About Her Reign

$
0
0

 


Miss USA 2022 Morgan Romano guested on Miss USA 2014 Nia Sanchez’s podcast where she reveals the struggles she experienced during her reign. Morgan was promoted to Miss USA after the original winner R’Bonney Gabriel won Miss Universe 2022.

Morgan told Nia that she paid all the expenses she had incurred during her reign with her own money. She also stated that she might probably have been the first Miss USA without a manager and she traveled alone to booked events. There was “no system” or point of contact because no one was running the Miss USA organization after its president Crystle Stewart was dismissed by the Miss Universe Organization.

“Behind the scenes, nothing was normal,” says Morgan.

Watch the entire interview on Nia’s YouTube channel, Nia Sanchez.

Amy Emmerich Resigns As CEO Of Miss Universe

$
0
0



Amy Emmerich, the CEO of the Miss Universe Organization, announced on her social media on February 8 that she will be stepping down from her position effective March 1st, 2024. She also announced that she will continue to be an advisor for the organization in the next few months. However, it is uncertain at this moment who will be the new CEO. Emmerich is the last major executive to leave MUO after Esther Swann, the former talent manager who left in March 2023 followed by Paula Shugart, the former president who resigned in November 2023.

As you know, Emmerich started her job with MUO in January 2022, which led to IMG selling MUO to JKN Global in October 2022. Under Emmerich’s leadership, the traditional entry requirements to compete in Miss Universe/Miss USA have been replaced by “progressive” ones that now allow women from all walks of life (beyond age limit of 28, married, mothers, grandmothers, divorced, pregnant, transwomen). Traditionalists do not like these updated requirements because they have “tarnished” the Miss Universe brand and have taken away the space usually reserved for single and childless young women between 18-28. Progressives counter-argue that the updated changes open doors for women whose dream of being a beauty queen may have been crushed by too many restrictions.
With Emmerich’s departure, this raises the question whether the new co-owner, Raul Rocha Cantú, who owns 50% of the company, will buy out the other co-owner, Anne Jakrajutatip, and fully own the company and maybe - and this is a big maybe - repeal Emmerich’s progressive policies and return to the traditional requirements.




Highlights From World Top Model 2024

$
0
0


 

  

The 6th World Top Model competition took place on February 10, 2024 at the New Yorker Hotel in New York City. 38 contestants competed in this year’s contest. Here are the official results: WTM Miss - Kaelyn Hollingsworth, Mississippi WTM Ms. - Breona Calvert, California WTM Teen - Ava Raiford, Virginia WTM USA - Isabella Key, Florida USA Swim Week Model - Cassidy Carpenter, Florida WTM Junior Ambassador - Olivia Zink, Connecticut WTM Little Ambassador - Kathleen Mountain, South Carolina I had the privilege to judge this competition for the third straight year in a row and I must say that it’s getting more and more competitive every year. I had the chance to speak to a few girls who did not win and encouraged them to come back next time and to never give up on their dreams like Breona Calvert who finally won a title on her third try! Huge shoutout to Rene Bionat of @beautyitseverywhere for producing the event and for providing opportunities for girls and women of all ages to showcase their talents. And a huge thank you for giving me another opportunity to be part of the judging panel. Congratulations to all the winners!

Miss World CEO Julia Morley Stresses Character Over Physical Beauty

$
0
0



As beauty standards evolve, we prioritise character, actions, and expressions over traditional norms: Julia Morley, Miss World Organisation. The chairperson and chief executive officer underscores the role of brand partnerships in driving the event's success and their ability to forge meaningful connections with audiences worldwide

 After a hiatus of 28 years, Miss World makes a return to India, heralding the onset of a global appeal that promises to captivate audiences worldwide.    The event is scheduled to take place on 9 March 2024 and the theme is 'beauty with a purpose'.    The festival embarks on a 21-day journey marked by on-ground events to engage with young women as agents of change and leaders of tomorrow, before D-day.    A total of 120 contestants representing nations from around the globe will converge in India, to compete in various competitions, to champion charitable initiatives, embodying the spirit of change and goodwill as ambassadors of their respective countries.


 Through dedicated media channels on the MissWorld.com platform, contestants will be able to showcase their talents and vie for a spot among the top 20 finalists for this year's pageant.    The live broadcast partnerships are forged with Sony LIV and production offerings will be handled by Endemol Shine India and Banijay Asia. For the events OOH responsibilities Bright Outdoor Media has been appointed.    In addition, Adsplash Agency will drive marketing endeavours and introduce valuable supporting partners to the Miss World Organisation's 'beauty with a purpose' program.   In an exclusive interview with Campaign India, Julia Morley, chairperson and chief executive officer of the Miss World Organisation, delves into the significance of leveraging India's cultural richness for brand associations and ensuring the event's continued relevance amidst evolving beauty pageant trends.  

Edited excerpts:    

What influenced the decision to bring Miss World back to India after 28 years?

Bringing the Miss World Festival to India holds a special significance for me, as my deep affection for this country is no secret. The long-awaited return of Miss World to India after 28 years is a testament to the collective efforts of everyone involved. A warm welcome is extended to the 120 Miss World Nations, whose 'beauty with a purpose' ambassadors have journeyed from across the globe to partake in the festivities.   The local community's enthusiasm in witnessing the endeavours of our young women adds to the joyous atmosphere, making India a cherished destination for families and youth alike, seeking both cultural enlightenment and a warm embrace.   

How will the Miss World Organisation leverage India's cultural richness for brand association?   

Brand partnerships are integral to the success of Miss World, exemplifying the importance of collaboration in driving meaningful initiatives forward.   

How will Endemol Shine India and Banijay Asia, as producers, elevate marketing and media coverage for the show and how does the Miss World Organisation ensure the event stays relevant amidst changing beauty pageant trends?   

In the realm of large-scale events, collaboration is key. Regardless of the industry, effective promotion and communication are essential. Our partnerships with Endemol Shine India and Banijay Asia hold significant importance as they facilitate the expansion of our streaming platform, fostering global connectivity. Through these alliances, we collectively contribute to the promotion and sales efforts, recognising the integral role played by every individual involved, from designers to models.   

We are fortunate to collaborate with various hotels, television networks, and media outlets in India, amplifying our message to a global audience spanning over 150 countries. Across generations, people are eager to stay informed about our initiatives.   

As beauty standards evolve within the industry, our focus shifts towards individuals' character, actions, and expressions rather than conventional notions of beauty or body types. Communication remains paramount, embracing diversity in every form without discrimination.   

There was a time in the 90s and early 2000s when India dominated Miss World during this period. Which are the biggest markets for you globally?

While India certainly excelled in pageant victories, its dominance didn't necessarily translate to market supremacy. Our winners have hailed from a variety of regions, spanning Latin America to Africa, showcasing the global diversity of our pageant.    

How does the Miss World Organisation plan to utilise MissWorld.com to engage audiences effectively, and how does it tailor marketing strategies to resonate with diverse global audiences?   

Websites play a crucial role in communication strategies. This year, we've launched a new website tailored to our needs. We need to assess the impact and effectiveness of this website moving forward.   

How will utilise social media to drive engagement and participation, and which media channel will telecast Miss World 2024 in India, and what influenced this decision? What else is in the media mix?   

Social media will play a vital role in our communication strategy, ensuring widespread engagement with our audience. Additionally, the 71st Miss World Festival will be live-streamed exclusively on our broadcast partner Sony LIV, offering comprehensive coverage of the event to viewers worldwide.   

Every section that we can dominate to get the word out we are on. We have people all over the place and in different mediums spreading the word. 


Source: https://www.campaignindia.in/article/as-beauty-standards-evolve-we-prioritise-character-actions-and-expressions-ove/494319
 

Anne JKN “Cleans House”

$
0
0

 





In this vlog, I discuss the latest stories revolving around Anne Jakrajutatip, or Khun Anne, the co-owner of Miss Universe. Anne's company, JKN Global, sold half of its shares to Legacy Holdings whose CEO is Mexican businessman Raul Rocha Cantu who is also the franchise owner of Miss Universe Mexico. To restructure and to revamp the Miss Universe Organization, Anne fired all the top American executive officers including Paula Shugart whom she labeled as “corrupted.”



Former MUO President Paula Shugart May Sue MUO Owner Anne Jakrajutatip

$
0
0

 


Former Miss Universe Organization President Paula Shugart, who resigned from her post last November, has released a statement on her Instagram on February 18, 2024 addressing the allegations against her made by MUO owner Anne Jakrajutatip. Paula is considering taking legal action against Anne. The post has generated strong reactions from fans most of whom support Paula.
Several titleholders expressed their support for Paula like the two former Miss Universe queens from Mexico, Lupita Jones (1991) and Ximena Navarrete (2010); Miss USA 2014 Nia Sanchez; and Miss USA 1998 Shawnae Jebbia. Miss Oregon USA 1994 Denise White, who judged Miss Universe 2023 finals, has some pretty harsh things to say about Anne. S
I’m sure more titleholders who have worked with Paula will share their thoughts soon. Meanwhile, I can imagine Anne pacing back and forth in her walk-in closet pulling her hair as she struggles to figure out how she is going to pay for a good lawyer. Here’s an idea, Anne: sell more fish sauce on TikTok! 😂
Okay, I shouldn’t be making fun of Anne because she’s already made a mockery of herself since she took over MUO and began tarnishing the brand with her eccentricity and carelessness. Now Karma has bit her in the ass and the bite will take a long time to heal. But I doubt anyone of us cares anymore.
What are your thoughts of Paula’s post? Comment below.




Miss Universe Video Scandal

$
0
0

 


IMPLODING UNIVERSE: Perhaps the biggest scandal of the Miss Universe organization was unleashed this Thursday, February 23, when the program "De Primera Mano", on Imagen TV , published leaked videos of a meeting headed by JKN Global CEO Anne Jakrajutatip and her team in Mexico that included MUO co-owner Raul Rocha Cantu, Cynthia de la Vega (new national director for Mexico). The meeting revealed the dark intentions of the organization which are only motivated by money. The videos were leaked by Rodrigo Goytortua, one of the terminated MUO workers who had recorded the meeting that took place in Mexico on October 23, 2023.

These are the main take-aways from the meeting:

- Anne said that the idea of inclusion that was realized during the 72nd edition, held last November 18 in El Salvador and that allowed plus-size, transgender women, mothers and married young people to participate, was only an advertising strategy to strengthen Anne's empire through a whole line of products - such as makeup and swimsuits - that have been part of the brand's innovation. They intend to repeat the same strategy this year - even more aggressively  - at the Mexican headquarters, with a reality show and a false message based on "inner beauty" regardless of age. In other words, inclusion is used only to gain viewer ratings and new consumers of MUO products.

- Anne said that all the contestants that fall in the "inclusion" category must believe that they can win, but that the organization will choose whoever suits them the best, implying that the judging panel is worthless. Cynthia de la Vega, the new national director of Mexico, tells Anne, "I like the way you think."

- The semi-finalists will be chosen based on the number of their social media followers; because it is better for the business. Incidentally, the only countries mentioned at the meeting were the Philippines, Thailand, Dominican Republic, France and India. Anne jokingly said that she wanted Thailand to win.

- Cynthia de la Vega said that "we have to make people forget about Mexicana Universal," - a jab against Lupita Jones, the former director who was dismissed without warning. Also, I find it funny that Cynthia literally says "you tell us which ones are the most worthy and we choose starting since that" They don't mention Nicaragua  in the meeting though (at least from what was seen). In fact the only delegates mentioned are India, Philippines, Thailand, Dominican Republic and France when highlighting the most power-worthy contestants for that year. The organization decides who should win.

- When selected Miss Universe 2023 contestants were flown to Mexico after the pageant, Rodrigo stated that the girls had been misled to believe that they would be attending   charity events which never materialized. Instead, they were only tasked to promote the brand and partnership between Anne and Raul. Rodrigo also said that he and his associates were told that they were allowed to do anything they wanted with the girls.

- Rodrigo was never paid for his services, and neither were international employees. When he asked Raul why he was never paid, Raul made several threats to him, that he would take him to court and send him to jail, and that he and his friend Salvador threatened to kill Rodrigo during a phone call which he was able to record. Rodrigo also said that if something happened to him or to his family, it would be Raul's doing. He has already filed a lawsuit against Raul who owes him millions.

- Raul wants the national directors to buy products from his various businesses, and that they also create a reality show in their respective countries that would follow the format for which they will also have to pay. Their elected queens will have to sell MUO skincare products on the reality show to make more money for the company.

- When asked if there are other things in the video that the viewers have not seen and that Rodrigo wanted to add, he said there are many things that are very delicate, but he cannot say them due to a pending lawsuit. He did say that an arrest warrant for Anne has been issued in Thailand and in Mexico and that Anne has scammed investors and filed for bankruptcy.


You can watch the entire show in Spanish here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OOyNJiDTIj0 



Group Chat on the Miss Universe Video Scandal, Miss World Updates and More

$
0
0

 



This group chat was conducted via Zoom on Saturday, February 25, 2024 at 9:00 PM EST. Mg guests include Noemi Melendez, Gaspar Cruz, Antonio Rivadeneira and Ed Dominguez.




First Miss USA Jackie Loughery Passes Away

$
0
0



 Jackie Loughery, former Miss USA and Miss Universe contestant, passed away at the age of 93. Loughery was an actress and the first woman to win the Miss USA title in the year 1952.


The news were shared on the Miss Universe social media account. “We are sorry to share that Jackie Loughery, the first ever Miss USA, has passed away. Jackie Loughery will be remembered as a woman who made history being the first Miss USA to compete at the first Miss Universe competition in 1952 and a trailblazer in the pageant community,” reads the post. “May you rest in power and peace.”

Viewers shared their condolences in the comments section, sharing how much Loughery meant to them. “A truly beautiful soul for anyone who ever got the chance to be in her presence,” wrote business personality Thom Brodeur. “Rest in peace icon,” wrote Athenna Crosby, the first runner up of Miss World America.

Loughery represented the USA in the first Miss Universe pageant, where she placed in ninth place.

Following her success in the beauty industry, Loughery entered the entertainment world, becoming an actress and appearing in various films. Her credits include “Pardners,” “The D.I.,” and various TV show roles like “Perry Mason.” She was also featured in the game show “Earn Your Vacation,” where she served as Johnny Carson’s assistant.

Loughery married various men over the course of her life. In 1952, she married singer Guy Mitchell. The two divorced in 1955. She then married actor Jack Webb, in 1958, with them getting a divorce in 1964. Her last marriage was with Jack W. Schwietzer, in 1969, with the two remaining married until his death, in 2009.

Source: https://www.hola.com/us/celebrities/20240226356480/miss-usa-jackie-loughery-passed-away/



 






Why Was Paula Shugart Absent At The MUO Executive Meeting In Mexico?

$
0
0

 

Guest Ed Dominguez, who is the franchise owner of Miss World Panama, raised the question as to why Paula Shugart was not present at the Miss Universe Organization executive meeting that took place in Mexico last October 23, 2023. Shugart resigned from MUO a month later. This is an excerpt from a group chat from February 25, 2024 that you can watch in full here: https://www.youtube.com/live/pBvUZWku...




Did Paula Shugart & Amy Emmerich Destroy Miss Universe?

$
0
0

 


In this clip, I share a message that pageant and Critical Beauty follower Sabrina Solomon of Singapore had sent me on Instagram expressing her sentiment on the Miss Universe video scandal. This is an excerpt from a group chat from February 25, 2024 that you can watch in full here: https://www.youtube.com/live/pBvUZWku...



Who Will Be Crowned The 71st Miss World?

$
0
0


This group chat was conducted via Zoom on Thursday, March 7, 2024 at 10:00 PM EST. My guests include Ed Dominguez, Antonio Rivadeneira, Julio Rodriguez, George of the Pageant Empress and Lenka Vomocil.

Watch with timestamps.



 

Czech Republic Is Crowned The 71st Miss World

$
0
0



The new Miss World is Krystyna Pyszkova, 23, of Czech Republic who was crowned in March 9, 2024 at Jio World Convention Centre in Mumbai, India.  

The first runner-up is Yasmina Zaytoun, 21, of Lebanon.

The other two finalists are Lesego Chombo of Botswana and Aché Abrahams of Trinidad and Tobago. 

Completing the top 8 and winning the continental queen titles are: Leticia Frota of Brazil (Miss World Americas & Caribbean), Jessica Gagen of England (Miss World Europe), Sini Shetty of India (Miss World Asia & Oceania) and Hannah Tumukunde of Uganda (Miss World Africa).  




Krystyna is the second woman from her country to win Miss World, the first being Tatana Kucharova in 2006.

Congratulations to the winner and finalists!

Miss Universe Costa Rice Bans Transwomen

$
0
0

 



    The Miss Universe Costa Rica Organization, in charge of choosing the Costa Rican representative for Miss Universe 2024, confirmed that trans women will not be able to participate in this edition of the contest.

    This was announced by Yessenia Ramírez, director of the beauty contest, during an interview with La Nación: “In the last beauty contests (in the world) trans women have been participating, who are medically and legally recognized as women. What about that requirement? Are they no longer going to be allowed?”

    Ramírez replied: “I want to handle this in a very sensitive way, for the respect that that population deserves. For me we are all the same and we all deserve the same respect, but, in this specific case, this contest is for women and that is something that even the same people demand. It is not our issue, if it is not something that is to do justice to women, so to speak.”

Source: https://www.nacion.com/viva/farandula/miss-universe-costa-rica-mujeres-trans-no-podran/MRZ3N3JYXBB7ZFAHUM46WP3JWE/story/?outputType=amp-type


Philippines Wins Universal Woman 2024

$
0
0

 


Maria Gigante, 30, representing the Philippines, has been crowned Universal Woman 2024 on March 22, 2024 in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. She is the first woman from her country to win the title. She was crowned by outgoing queen Valentina Sanchez Trivella of Venezuela.

Her court includes:

1st runner-up - Lisandra Chirinos - Venezuela
2nd runner-up - Elise Mysyshyne - France
3rd runner-up - Brianna Mai - Cambodia
4th runner-up - Tavera Pena Chabeli - Dominican Republic

Making the top 12 were the delegates from Zimbabwe, Denmark, Cuba, Argentina, Brazil, Puerto Rico and Great Britain.

A total of 42 contestants competed in the second edition of the pageant whose aim is to “unite, celebrate and advance women’s contribution, diverse beauty and accomplishments.” The contest is open to women between 25 to 45 years of age regardless of marital status.




Miss Universe Denies Saudi Arabian Candidate Joining Pageant

$
0
0

 

Rumy Alqahtani will reportedly represent Saudi Arabia in Miss Universe 2024, however, it has been denied by the Miss Universe organization. Image: Instagram/@rumy_alqahtani


The Miss Universe Organization (MUO) denied reports of Saudi Arabia sending a representative in the upcoming global tilt, saying that “no selection process” was made to determine whether she qualifies for the pageant.

The 27-year-old Rumy Alqahtani made headlines after she announced on her Instagram page on March 25 that she was “honored” to be named the Arab country’s “first representative” for Miss Universe 2024.

In her post, the beauty queen could be seen posing with the national flag of Saudi Arabia in her sparkly tube gown and tiara.

“We would like to categorically state that no selection process was conducted in Saudi Arabia, and any such claims are false and misleading,” the statement read. “The selection of contestants to represent their respective countries in the Miss Universe competition is a rigorous process that adheres strictly to our policies and guidelines.

The pageant organization pointed out that candidates must go through its “criteria and regulations” to ensure “fairness and transparency” is made, before they will represent their country.

“While Saudi Arabia is not yet among these countries fully confirmed participating this year, we are currently undergoing a rigorous vetting process qualifying a potential candidate to be awarded the franchise and assigned national director to represent,” MUO added.


The MUO statement further said the Middle East nation’s participation remains void until its approval committee gave its seal of approval. “Saudi Arabia will not have this opportunity to join our prestigious pageant until this is final and confirmed by our approval committee.”

“As we prepare for the upcoming edition of the Miss Universe contest in Mexico, we are proud to announce that we will welcome over 100 contestants from various nationalities around the world,” it continued, saying it will continue to promote “diversity and inclusivity” in its upcoming edition.

Alqahtani has yet to comment on MUO’s statement, as of this writing.


Source:
https://entertainment.inquirer.net/549869/miss-universe-denies-saudi-arabian-candidate-joining-pageant

 

Samoa Returns To Miss Universe

$
0
0

 



Samoa returns to Miss Universe! On April 3, 2024, Manaia Event launched the Miss Universe Samoa pageant that will pick a Samoan representative to the 2024 Miss Universe contest held in Mexico in November.

Director of Miss Universe Samoa, Leiataualesa Jerry Brunt, revealed that Miss Universe organization granted them the license to organize and recruit a candidate to represent Samoa, with efforts underway to finalize the selection criteria.

Leiataualesa disclosed that they have asked MUO to consider exemptions for Samoa, for example, regarding traditional Samoan tattoos such as the malu worn by Samoan girls. 

Vodafone Samoa, serving as the telecommunication partner for Miss Universe Samoa, pledged support and knowledge-sharing throughout the journey, building on their successful collaboration in sending Samoa’s first-ever contestant to the Miss Global pageant last year.

Source: https://www.samoaobserver.ws/category/samoa/108673

Samoa has competed in Miss Universe from 1975 to 1978, and then from 1981 until 1986 with the participation of Tu’iamanu’ula Kaye Hunt. The country has never placed.



Miss Samoa Palepa Sio Tauiliili with Miss Papua-New Guinea and Miss Thailand at Miss Universe 1978 pageant in Acapulco, Mexico.






Latest Images